Skip to main content

Cautionary Note: Resist the Temptation of Dual Agency

Definition: Dual agency is when a single real estate agent handles both sides of a real estate transaction. This means they represent both the buyer and the seller. It can also occur when an agent represents both the landlord and the tenant, or when the same real estate company represents both parties in a purchase and sale or rental transaction.

Recent developments, such as the National Association of Realtors (NAR) settlement on buyer agent commissions, have sparked discussions within the real estate community, particularly concerning buyer representation and the risks associated with dual agency.

Dual agency is never a good idea for buyers or sellers.

At first glance, the concept of a single agent representing both buyer and seller may seem convenient and cost-effective. The notion of the listing agent potentially offering a reduced price to avoid splitting commissions could be enticing for buyers. However, before committing to a dual agency arrangement, it’s essential to grasp the potential pitfalls.

Why Dual Agency Poses Risks

The primary concern lies in the inherent conflict of interest. A seller’s agent aims to secure the highest possible price, while a buyer’s agent strives to obtain the best deal. How can one agent ethically navigate both sides of this negotiation?

Consider these potential disadvantages of dual agency:

  1. Limited Negotiating Power: Dual agents are constrained in their ability to negotiate aggressively on your behalf. They may be unable to disclose crucial details such as the seller’s bottom line or your maximum offer, hampering your ability to secure the most favorable price.
  2. Information Imbalance: Vital information about the property’s condition or the seller’s motivations might not be fully disclosed, placing you at a disadvantage.
  3. Compromised Loyalty: Despite ethical obligations, the financial incentive to expedite the deal for a higher commission may influence decision-making.

Protecting Your Interests

How can you safeguard yourself in such situations? Consider the following strategies:

  1. Seek Independent Representation: Opt for a dedicated buyer’s agent who works exclusively for you. They possess market insights, negotiate vigorously, and advocate for your interests throughout the process.
  2. Prioritize Transparency: If contemplating dual agency, ensure you comprehend its limitations and potential drawbacks fully. Request a detailed explanation of your agent’s fiduciary duty and insist on written documentation.
  3. Trust Your Instincts: If you sense any discomfort or doubt regarding the agent’s impartiality, don’t hesitate to seek out another Realtor® who places your interests above all else.

Remember, purchasing a home is a significant investment. Don’t allow the allure of a potentially lower price to cloud your judgment. Ultimately, a proficient buyer’s agent can save you money by securing a superior deal and shielding you from potential pitfalls.

If you have questions, call Alex at (760) 808-3300.